To contact HHRI, please do so via email. Thank you!

Heartland Health Research Institute

HHRI

  • Home
  • About
    • About HHRI
    • Customized Research in Healthcare
    • Board Members
    • FAQ
  • Posts
  • Publications
    • HHRI Studies – Overview
      • Iowans’ Views on Medical Errors – Iowa Patient Safety Study©
    • White Papers – Overview
      • ‘Silently Harmed’
        • Silently Harmed in the Heartland
        • Silently Harmed – Illinois
        • Silently Harmed – Iowa
        • Silently Harmed – Minnesota
        • Silently Harmed – Missouri
        • Silently Harmed – Nebraska
        • Silently Harmed – South Dakota
        • Silently Harmed – Wisconsin
      • ‘Voices for Value’
    • Infographics – Overview
      • Iowans’ Views on Medical Errors
      • Silently Harmed in the U.S.
      • Our Health Care River
  • Media
    • Press Releases
    • In the News
  • Contact

A Reason to Donate Anonymously?

Posted on: 02.12.19 By: David P. LindLeave a Comment

A Reason to Donate Anonymously?When donating to your favorite charities (or candidates), do you usually allow your donations to become acknowledged publicly or do you prefer to give anonymously? Perhaps your answer depends on the specific charity or candidate, or maybe it depends on how much you are donating. By the way, there really is no right or wrong answer to this question. However, you may change your views after reading this post.

What would you think if your donation history to various charitable causes may determine whether or not you will be ‘targeted’ by your local nonprofit hospital to become a donor to their organization?

Nonprofit Hospital Fundraising

Research shows that this happens relatively frequently. In fact, you may even be a patient at the time you are ‘solicited.’ Through highly-defined prospect research results on your past-giving behaviors, you may qualify to receive a visit by a hospital administrator or someone representing the philanthropic arm of the hospital. The donations sought are to supplement income streams hospitals have from other sources, such as private and public insurance payers and money raised through more traditional (and transparent) methods, such as charity golf tournaments, galas, etc.

This issue caught my attention recently after reading a Kaiser Health News article. According to the article, ‘many’ nonprofit hospitals across the U.S. conduct “nightly wealth screenings” of their patients. They use software “that culls public data such as public records, contributions to political campaigns and other charities – to gauge which patients are most likely to be the source of large donations.” According to this article, these programs “are becoming commonplace, particularly among the largest nonprofit hospitals.” This practice is also known as ‘Grateful Patient Programs.’

If Solicited as a Patient, It’s Legal

Protected health information (PHI), which is part of the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, is usually a good thing for patients. In fact, PHI was designed to be given only to authorized individuals and organizations. Yet, since 2013, certain healthcare providers are allowed greater flexibility to use PHI for fundraising purposes, such as the nature of the services a patient received or the identity of his or her physician. According to The Giving Institute, healthcare organizations may use the following patient’s PHI without having their authorization for fundraising purposes:

  • Patient demographic data (name, address, phone/email, date of birth, age, gender, etc.)
  • Health insurance status
  • Dates of patient services
  • General type of department in which a patient is serviced
  • Treating physician information
  • Outcome information
Written patient authorization is required prior to fundraising under the following:

  • Diagnosis
  • Nature of services
  • Treatment
The 2013 change in federal health privacy law made it easier for hospitals to target their patients for donations, enabling the hospital records department to share with staff fundraisers some personal details of patients, as outlined above. When admitted to a hospital, patients (or a family member) are required to fill out paperwork permitting the hospital to use PHI for fundraising purposes. The federal law does require hospitals to inform patients they have the right to decline being solicited, but few patients are aware of this due to the bevy of legal paperwork they are given during the time of admittance.

Major Des Moines Medical Centers?

This rather opaque process of soliciting qualified patients for donations prompted me to contact the media relations departments of Des Moines’ two largest hospital systems: Mercy Medical Center (now MercyOne) and UnityPoint Health Des Moines. As of this post’s publication, neither organization has responded to my emails to confirm whether or not they have such a program in place.

Hospitals are granted a tool that allows them to legally solicit donations from patients and family members, especially when they are held ‘captive’ within their facilities due to medical purposes. The Kaiser article does raise a question that many of us may ponder: Will care be affected depending on whether a large donation is possible or not? In other words, could we potentially have a two-tier care system, one for the wealthy and one for everyone else?

This fundraising approach does allow one to reason that perhaps more of our future personal donations should be made anonymously.

To stay abreast of healthcare-related issues, we invite you to subscribe to this blog.

Categories: HHRI Tags: Grateful Patient Programs, Kaiser Health News, MercyOne, The Giving Institute, UnityPoint Health

Leave a Comment Cancel

Autonomist: The independence to share one's thoughts and to have the freedom from external control or influence.

Subscribe to The Health Autonomist!

* indicates required

Recent Posts

  • More Accurate Death Certificates are Necessary December 9, 2021
  • Promotion of a Healthy Workforce – Part 5 November 9, 2021
  • Employers: Establishing A Culture of Healthfulness – Part 4 November 2, 2021
  • Obesity – a Disease or a Choice? (Part 3) October 26, 2021
  • Is the Body Mass Index (BMI) Useful? (Part 2) October 19, 2021

Contact Us | © 2022 Heartland Health Research Institute. All rights reserved | Privacy Policy | Terms of Use